“I can’t imagine being in love right now.”
He said it as we were standing on the train platform, both of us facing the sign that warns you not to step on the third rail—looking through it. My stomach did a calculated jump. I didn’t know I wasn’t ready to hear those words.
“What do you mean?”
I looked to the left to see if I could see the train coming towards the tracks and feign indifference.
“It’s just so stressful. To care about someone,” he took his hands out of his pockets and rubbed them together. He looked down the length of his body and zipped his coat up tighter. “It takes so much effort.”
I creeped my chin back into my scarf to hide the way my mouth was dropping open. He couldn’t have known back then how much I wanted to be anywhere near those hands. They looked the way I imagined Paul Newman’s hands would, with a few casual calluses. Even the way he would maneuver them, they seemed honest and hardworking without trying. I turned my head to watch him fiddle with his zipper only to be overcome with hand-lust. I instantly wanted his hands all over me. He self-consciously shoved them back into his jacket pockets. I shuffled the soles of my shoes against the splinters of the platform.
“That’s too bad. That you would think that love isn’t worth the work. I mean, it’s work… but I don’t know about cutting it out.”
“I’m not saying I don’t want it—I just can’t imagine having to do all those… things, you know? The things you have to do when you’re in love. All the time spent together, all the worrying, all the emotions.” He took time to squint across the apartment skyline.
“It’s a labor of love,” I winced at the cliché as I felt it cut crisply across the air between us, making our separation increase tenfold.
“It’s too much.” He looked right at me.
There was no pretense to this conversation, no way to know how or why such a topic emerged from the depths of his mind, but there it was. A revelation from an otherwise stoic figure.
And even with such a definitive statement sitting in front of me, I couldn’t help but to think back to our years of friendship. When he would hold me just because he knew I needed to be held. Or when I would call him at three, four in the morning when he was dumped in the middle of the night and needed to wake up the next morning and pretend like it hadn’t happened. We knew not to talk or give perspective in those situations.
That was what made it was so painful to look at him then, with the train about to wind tunnel from behind him. Every part of him was lying to me but there we stood, together, in that wonderful moment before the train came rushing past us. Like the apex of a breath, after the inhale and right before the exhale, our bodies stood floating through this new space that we had created. Until the first car came by as it always intended to, making a fist of frigid air and punching us both in the face. We turned away and covered our faces from it and one another out of instinct.
“I don’t want to talk about this.” He said a little louder than the train brakes, taking my hand. I let him lead me onto the car, like we had always intended to do, and put his arm around me without the need for anything more.